News

Plutarch Award 2013

Plutarch medallion

Announcing the First-Ever Prize for Best Biography of the Year as Selected by Biographers;
List of Nominees Revealed

New York, NY—For the first time ever, biographers will determine the best biography of the year when they bestow the Plutarch Award at a gala ceremony in New York City on May 18.

Named after the famous Ancient Greek biographer, the prize aims to be the genre’s equivalent of the Oscar, in that the winner will be determined by secret ballot from a list of nominees selected by a committee of distinguished members of the craft.

The 2012 books nominated for this year’s inaugural Plutarch are:

  • Deirdre Bair, Saul Steinberg: A Biography (Nan A. Talese)
  • Robert Caro, The Passage of Power (Knopf)
  • Lisa Cohen, All We Know: Three Lives (Farrar, Straus and Giroux)
  • Timothy Egan, Short Nights of the Shadow Catcher: The Epic Life and Immortal Photographs of Edward Curtis (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt)
  • Alice Kessler-Harris, A Difficult Woman, The Challenging Life and Times of Lillian Hellman (Bloomsbury Press)
  • David Maraniss, Barack Obama, The Story (Simon & Schuster)
  • John Matteson, The Lives of Margaret Fuller (W. W. Norton & Company)
  • Tom Reiss, The Black Count: Glory, Revolution, Betrayal, and the Real Count of Monte Cristo (Crown)
  • William Souder, On a Farther Shore: The Life and Legacy of Rachel Carson (Crown)
  • Rachel L. Swarns, American Tapestry: The Story of the Black, White and Multiracial Ancestors of Michelle Obama (Amistad)

“This is the first prize to be awarded to a biographer by biographers,” said BIO President James McGrath Morris. “Just as each year science fiction readers await the announcement of the Nebula, horror readers await the Stoker, and mystery fans await the Edgar, we aim to make the Plutarch a similarly prestigious and much-sought-after award for biographers and readers of biography.”

The Plutarch Award winner will be revealed at BIO’s annual Compleat Biographer Conference in New York City on May 18th, which attracts hundreds of biographers from around the globe.

 

New Radio Show Featuring Biographers Premieres

A discussion of gender and whether biographers can write about subjects of a different gender were part of a lively discussion between members of BIO on new monthly radio program devoted to biography.

The program, called “Collected Words,” is produced by Collected Works Bookstore in Santa Fe, New Mexico. It premièred on April 3 on KVSF. BIO president James McGrath Morris served as host to inaugural guests Carl Rollyson, who just published a biography of Sylvia Plath, and Megan Marshall, whose new book on Margaret Fuller came out last month.

The show will air weekly, but only the first program of each month will be devoted to biography. You can hear the first program on this archived podcast.

Panel Offers Encouraging News on Biography Market

By Dona Munker, TBC New York correspondent

The overall market for biographies remains steady, according to three trade publishing veterans who spoke at a recent meeting of the New York University Biography Seminar, organized by BIO member Gayle Feldman.

The February 20 panel comprised Jonathan Galassi, a former editor and current president of Farrar, Straus & Giroux; Eric Simonoff, head of the literary division of William Morris Endeavor Entertainment; and biographer James Atlas, who was recently appointed the editor of a series of biographies for a joint venture between Amazon Publishing and Houghton Mifflin Harcourt and will be speaking at the 2013 Compleat Biographer conference.

Considering the turmoil besetting traditional publishing as a result of e-books, the three panelists surprisingly didn’t think that the overall market for biography had changed much. In fact, the consensus was that in 2012, biography sales in the US remained steady and were driven by the same two factors that have dominated this market niche for decades: the desire of publishers to sign up biographers who write about monumental subjects and have high name recognition, and the biography-reading public’s apparently immutable desire for familiar names and subjects. Nonetheless, Galassi said that after forty years of publishing, he didn’t think serious biography is “doing any worse than in the past.”

To add to such (relatively) good news, some publishers are showing a continuing interest in short-form biography, which springs at least in part from the digital revolution. James Atlas, who revived the popular “biographical essay” associated with Lytton Strachey by bringing it up to date in his Penguin Lives series, has a mandate from Amazon to sign up twelve similar books about well-known figures by noted authors. He is seeking writers who can cover the subject quickly and engagingly, and he’s encouraging them “to explore their own relationship with the subject” in the narrative—for example, how they became interested in the story. Atlas said that he was convinced that a market exists for “discovery biographies” of fewer than 40,000 words, of which he currently has two under contract. Amazon’s New Harvest will distribute the books electronically and Houghton Mifflin Harcourt will distribute the hardcover editions.

The panelists agreed that the future of biography remains hard to predict. Both publishers and booksellers have traditionally been secretive about statistics and sales figures. Nevertheless, as Galassi observed, publishers are still buying—and getting excited about—biographies they know will be influential, regardless of how those biographies can be expected to sell. “Books that are doing pioneering work have to struggle in today’s marketplace,” he said. “But good books always have.”

Eric Simonoff, the literary agent, whose clients at William Morris may get anywhere from mid-five to low-six figure advances, cautioned that those advances don’t always amount to much over the length of time needed to research and write a biography. Galassi, however, didn’t think that biographers who write for the love of the subject or the craft necessarily need to despair, since any proposal for a biography that is sharply focused and well-written may indeed find an enthusiastic publisher, though perhaps not a large, well-heeled trade publisher.

All of which may simply go to show how little things change. As Gayle Feldman noted in her introduction, even in the early years of the twentieth century, the famed publisher Bennett Cerf, while lamenting what he regarded as biography’s general mediocrity and “lack of distinction,” nevertheless conceded that “the right book or the right author can always puncture any generalizations that can be laid down.”

Dona Munker is the writer and co-author of Daughter of Persia: A Woman’s Journey from Her Father’s Harem through the Islamic Revolution.  She is currently working on a book about the twentieth-century American poet, suffragist, and “free-lover” Sara Bard Field. She also, as time allows, has a blog about biography called “Stalking the Elephant.”

Spring Biographical Offerings

While the fall remains the favorite season for publishers to bring out their heavy hitters, there is no lack of substantial and important biographies on the spring list of 2013. Here are some titles, among many, likely to garner considerable attention.

Ike and Dick: Portrait of a Strange Political Marriage by Jeffrey Frank will be published by Simon & Schuster this month and was touted in a recent issue of the New Yorker. In April the company will bring out the long-awaited Bolivar: American Liberator by former Washington Post book editor Marie Arana.

American Isis: The Life and Art of Sylvia Plath by Carl Rollyson was published in January by St. Martin’s Press. Two other books about the poet will follow it. Mad Girl’s Love Song: Sylvia Plath and Life Before Ted by Andrew Wilson will be published by Scribner this month, and Pain, Parties, Work: Sylvia Plath in New York, Summer 1953 by Elizabeth Winder will come out from Harper in April.

Another female writer on the list of subjects for the spring is Jane Austen (can one ever have too many books on her?). The Real Jane Austen: A Life in Small Things by Paula Byrne, came out in January from Harper.

Along the lines of calling a biography “real,” Henry Holt published Andrew Marr’s The Real Elizabeth: An Intimate Portrait of Queen Elizabeth II last month.

A forgotten American president gets his due this month, when Harper delivers Amity Shlaes’s Coolidge and next month, Encounter Books offers a companion book, Why Coolidge Matters: Leadership Lessons from America’s Most Underrated President by Charles C. Johnson.

Megan Marshall’s Margaret Fuller: A New American Life will be published in March by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. Last year, Fuller was the subject of John Matteson’s most recent biography. Andrea Pitzer’s The Secret History of Vladimir Nabokov will also be published in March by Houghton.

Blake Bailey, biographer of John Cheever, is back with a new work with the unusual title Farther and Wilder: The Lost Weekends and Literary Dreams of Charles Jackson, which Knopf will publish in March.

For readers old enough to remember what television was once like, in April Viking is bringing out Flip: The Inside Story of TV’s First Black Superstar by Kevin Cook.

Recording artist, songwriter, entrepreneur, voice actor, record producer, educator, and philanthropist William James Adams’s life is the subject of Will.i.am: The Unauthorized Biography by Danny White from publisher Michael O’Mara [Note to editor: That’s not a typo in the title].

For readers who loved the old American Heritage magazine, Scribner is publishing I Invented the Modern Age: The Rise of Henry Ford by Richard Snow, who edited the magazine in its heyday.

Yale University continues its tradition of producing attention-getting biographies. It already began the season with biographies of two noted subjects: The Great Agnostic: Robert Ingersoll and American Freethought by Susan Jacoby and Eslanda: The Large and Unconventional Life of Mrs. Paul Robeson by Barbara Ransby

On the heels of David Nasaw’s biography of Joseph Kennedy, out last fall, comes Rose Kennedy: The Life and Times of a Political Matriarch by Barbara A. Perry, which W. W. Norton & Company will publish in July.

Biography Club prize winner Clare Mulley’s The Spy Who Loved: The Secrets and Lives of Christine Granville will come out in June in an American edition by St. Martin’s Press.

And, lastly, for those who once drove a car with an eight-track tape player, comes The Bee Gees: The Biography by David N. Meyer from Da Capo Press

Click here for a detailed listing of more than fifty spring 2013 biographies on the BIO website.

Great Lives Series Kicks Off

The 10th anniversary season of the Chappell Great Lives Lecture Series began last month, with Philip Freeman speaking about Julius Caesar. The lectures, which are free and typically draw several hundred people, are sponsored by the University of Mary Washington in Fredericksburg, Virginia.

In the months to come, the lectures will look at the lives of such diverse figures as Brigham Young, Rasputin, Marian Anderson, Michelangelo, and Walter Cronkite. Lecturers will include BIO member Carl Rollyson, Sally Bedell Smith, Michael Burlingame, and Arnold Rampersad, winner of the 2012 BIO Award.

BIO is a proud program affiliate of the Great Lives Series, with BIO vice president Brian Jay Jones serving as the liaison with the university. In an interview with fredericksburg.com, Jones noted, “A good biography is a great life well-told. A great life can even be a small life well-told. Everyone’s got a compelling story.”

To see the complete lineup, visit the program’s website.

Researcher to the Stars Offers Tips

Here is the complete interview with researcher and writer Michael Hill from the February issue of The Biographer’s Craft.

TBC: You’ve just been hired for a new biographical project, or are beginning one of your own.  Briefly, what are your first steps in beginning research?

Hill: First, find out what manuscript collections are in existence and are they currently open to researchers. Where are they located and how extensive are they—i.e., do they contain diaries, correspondence, notebooks, and photographs? Not only would I be interested in collections concerning the subject of the biography, but also collections of people who knew the subject, were related to him or worked with him. Related to this is to find out what, if any, oral history collections exist. Finally, is there audiovisual material related to the subject in any of the archives? Second, find out if anyone is still alive who knew the subject: children, spouses, staff members, contemporaries and/or journalists. Not only might they be a good interview, but oftentimes these people have diaries or letters or other materials which would not be found in any archive and can be extraordinarily useful.
Third, what newspapers and other periodicals might have covered the subject and his or her time period? The Library of Congress has an exceptional collection of newspapers which I have used over the years.
Fourth, what museums or house museums might still exist which relate to the subject of the biography?
Fifth, if it is a military subject, find out if the battlefields or theater of operations still exist. Seeing these sites firsthand can provide tremendous insight and detail for specific scenes.

 

TBC: Are there any common (or uncommon) research roadblocks, and if so, how do you get around them?
Hill: There are two: First, the scarcity or non-existence of archival material for the subject, and second, the existence of material which has not yet been processed or has restricted access to it.
One way to try and get around the first is to find people still alive who knew the subject. A personal interview can provide terrific insight, but also they may hold archival material which would never be found anywhere else. If no one is living, try and find manuscript collections of people who knew the subject. Diaries and letters of friends, relatives or colleagues can provide fabulous material and insight into your subject. Never, ever neglect to look at the letters or diaries of wives, daughters or mistresses. Over the years I have found true jewels in their letters or diaries.
For material which is restricted, find out if there is a living family member (or estate executor) who can allow access. The archivists at the various institutions are always helpful in trying to locate such contacts. Another hurdle, with modern presidential libraries, is material which is restricted by the Presidential Records Act. That is often a tough nut to crack.
With regard to material which exists, but has not been processed, unfortunately that is a matter which is often beyond your control and that of the individual archive. Most times it is a question of manpower and financial resources. The only suggestion I can offer is that occasionally an arrangement can be made with an archivist to process limited portions of a collection bearing on your subject, but this is tricky and is granted in only very rare cases.

 

TBC: Any others tips or words of encouragement for our members as they do their research?
Hill: It [his experience with the Washburne book] should be a source of encouragement to anyone who has a passion for history and has always thought about writing a book about history or biography. Just do it.

 

TBC: What led to you Elihu Washburne as the subject of your own book?
Hill: David McCullough and I came across the diary and letters while he was working on his The Greater Journey about Americans in Paris during the 19th century. After the book was published, many reviewers picked up on the Washburne story as one of the great characters and highlights of the book’s dramatic narrative. At that point, David thought it was important to have the entire diary published in book form, along with his personal letters and diplomatic correspondence during that historic period. Simon and Schuster agreed with him and asked me to do the editing.
Washburne is one of the great unknown characters of the 19th century who knew Ulysses S. Grant, President Lincoln, Napoleon III and was at center stage of two of the greatest struggles of the 19th century: the American Civil War and the Siege and Commune of Paris 1870-1871.

 

TBC: Was the research process any different from when you work for someone else?
Hill: Actually no. Working on books for nearly thirty years with some of our greatest writers was invaluable in making good use of my research and writing time.

 

TBC: Did you enjoy the writing process?
Hill: I enjoyed the whole writing process immensely. It was terrifying at first and I was unsure about whether I could pull it all off. But with encouragement from David McCullough and my editor, Bob Bender, I got through it.

 

Spring Books – 2013

 

JANUARY
Johnson and Boswell: A Biography of Friendship by John B. Radner (Yale University Press)
The Watchful Clothier: The Life of an Eighteenth-Century Protestant Capitalist by Matthew Kadane (Yale University Press)
Ravel by Roger Nichols (Yale University Press)
George II: King and Elector by Andrew C. Thompson (Yale University Press)
Hawthorne’s Habitations: A Literary Life by Robert Milder (Oxford University Press)
The Pinecone: The Story of Sarah Losh, Forgotten Romantic Heroine—Antiquarian, Architect, and Visionary by Jenny Uglow (Farrar, Straus and Giroux)
Nancy: The Story of Lady Astor by Adrian Fort (St. Martin’s Press)
The Inventor and the Tycoon: A Gilded Age Murder and the Birth of Moving Pictures by Edward Ball (Doubleday)
Unhitched: The Trial of Christopher Hitchens by Richard Seymour (Verso)
Lee Marvin: Point Blank by Dwayne Epstein (Schaffner Press, Inc.)
The Rebellious Life of Mrs. Rosa Parks by Jeanne Theoharis (Beacon Press)
Davis McCaughey: A Life by Sarah Martin (University of New South Wales Press)
Soldier of Christ: The Life of Pope Pius XII by Robert A. Ventresca (Belknap Press)
Congressman Lincoln by Chris DeRose (Threshold Editions)
Declaring His Genius: Oscar Wilde in North America by Roy Morris (Belknap Press)

FEBRUARY
Ike and Dick: Portrait of a Strange Political Marriage by Jeffrey Frank (Simon & Schuster)
Louis Agassiz: Creator of American Science by Christoph Irmscher (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt)
The Best-Kept Boy in the World: The Life and Loves of Denny Fouts by Arthur Vanderbilt (Magnus Books)
Whitey: The Life of America’s Most Notorious Mob Boss by Dick Lehr and Gerard O’Neill (Crown)
The Force of Things: A Marriage in War and Peace by Alexander Stille (Farrar, Straus and Giroux)
Maverick Genius: The Pioneering Odyssey of Freeman Dyson by Phillip F. Schewe (Thomas Dunne Books)
The Last Love of George Sand: A Literary Biography by Evelyne Bloch-Dano (Arcade Publishing)
A Game of Three Halves: The Official Kenny Swain Biography by Brian Beard (Pitch Publishing)
The Master of Us All: Balenciaga, His Workrooms, His World by Mary Blume (Farrar, Straus and Giroux)
The Last Outlaws: The Lives and Legends of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid by Thom Hatch (Penguin Group)
Classic Modern: The Art Worlds of Joseph Pulitzer Jr. by Marjorie B. Cohn (Harvard Art Museums)
George Liele’s Life and Legacy: An Unsung Hero by David T. Shannon, Sr. & Julia Frazier White (Mercer University Press)

MARCH
American Hipster: A Life of Herbert Huncke, The Times Square Hustler Who Inspired the Beat Movement by Hilary Holladay (Magnus Books)
The Bird: The Life and Legacy of Mark Fidrych by Doug Wilson (Thomas Dunne Books)
Here I Am: The Story of Tim Hetherington, War Photographer by Alan Huffman (Grove Press)
Young Titan: The Making of Winston Churchill by Michael Shelden (Simon & Schuster)
Lady at the O.K. Corral: The True Story of Josephine Marcus Earp by Ann Kirschner (Harper)
Olivia Manning: A Woman at War by Deirdre David (Oxford University Press)
Lina and Serge: The Love and Wars of Lina Prokofiev by Simon Morrison (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt)
Hopper: A Journey into the American Dream by Tom Folsom (It Books)
C. S. Lewis: A Life: Eccentric Genius, Reluctant Prophet by Alister McGrath (Tyndale House Publishers)
Karl Marx: A Nineteenth-Century Life by Jonathan Sperber (Liveright)
The House of Redgrave: The Lives of a Theatrical Dynasty by Tim Adler (Aurum Press)

APRIL
The Philosopher, the Priest, and the Painter: A Portrait of Descartes by Steven Nadler (Princeton University Press)
Peter Cushing: A Life in Film by David Miller (Titan Books)
Polka King: The Life and Times of Polka Music’s Living Legend by Jimmy Sturr (BenBella Books)
Worldly Philosopher: The Odyssey of Albert O. Hirschman by Jeremy Adelman (Princeton University Press)
Franz Kafka: The Poet of Shame and Guilt by Saul Friedlander (Yale University Press)
First Son: The Biography of Richard M. Daley by Keith Koeneman (University of Chicago Press)
Augie’s Secrets: The Minneapolis Mob and the King of the Hennepin Strip by Neal Karlen
(Minnesota Historical Society Press)
The Creation of Anne Boleyn: A New Look at England’s Most Notorious Queen by Susan Bordo (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt)
Nailed!: The Improbable Rise and Spectacular Fall of Lenny Dykstra by Christopher Frankie (Running Press)
Shadow Warrior: William Egan Colby and the CIA by Randall B. Woods (Basic Books)

MAY
Tesla: Inventor of the Electrical Age by W. Bernard Carlson (Princeton University Press)
Permanent Present Tense: The Unforgettable Life of the Amnesic Patient, H.M. by Suzanne Corkin (Basic Books)
Nâzim Hikmet: The Life and Times of Turkey’s World Poet by Mutlu Konuk Blasing (Persea)
Uncommon Youth: The Gilded Life and Tragic Times of J. Paul Getty III by Charles Fox (St. Martin’s Press)
Thomas Aquinas: A Portrait by Denys Turner (Yale University Press)
Noel Gallagher: The Biography by Lucian Randall (John Blake)
Why Always Me?: The Biography of Mario Balotelli by Frank Worrall (John Blake)
Passionate Commitments: The Lives of Anna Rochester and Grace Hutchins by Julia M. Allen (SUNY Press)
All the Great Prizes: The Life of John Hay, from Lincoln to Roosevelt by John Taliaferro (Simon & Schuster)
The DiMaggios by Tom Clavin (Ecco)
Alexander Wilson: The Scot Who Founded American Ornithology by Edward H. Burtt & William E. Davis (Belknap Press)
Edmund Burke: The First Conservative by Jesse Norman (Basic Books)
Robert Oppenheimer: A Life Inside the Center by Ray Monk (Doubleday)
Curious Man: The Strange and Brilliant Life of Robert “Believe It or Not!” Ripley by Neal Thompson (Crown Archetype)
James J. Kilpatrick: Salesman for Segregation by William P. Hustwit (The University of North Carolina Press)
Josephus Daniels: His Life and Times by Lee Craig (University of North Carolina Press)
Arthur Erickson: An Architect’s Life by David Stouck (Douglas & McIntyre)

JUNE
Kafka: The Years of Insight by Reiner Stach & Shelley Frisch (Princeton University Press)
Dreadful: The Short Life and Gay Times of John Horne Burns by David Margolick (Other Press)
George Washington: The Crossing by Jack E Levin & Mark R. Levin (Threshold Editions)
Gloria Swanson: The Ultimate Star by Stephen Michael Shearer & Jeanine Basinger ( Thomas Dunne Books)
Queen Bee of Tuscany: The Redoubtable Janet Ross by Ben Downing (Farrar, Straus and Giroux)
The First Chinese American: The Remarkable Life of Wong Chin Foo by Scott D. Seligman ( Hong Kong University Press)
Dashiell Hammett: Man of Mystery by Sally Cline (Arcade Publishing)
Nelson: The Sword of Albion by John Sugden (Henry Holt and Co.)
Churchill’s White Rabbit: The True Story of a Real-life James Bond by Sophie Jackson (The History Press)

JULY
The Red Man’s Bones: George Catlin, Artist and Showman by Benita Eisler (W. W. Norton & Company)
Full Steam Ahead!: The Life and Art of Ward Kimball by Amid Amidi (Chronicle Books)
Gandhi: A Spiritual Biography by Arvind Sharma (Yale University Press)
Rav Kook: Mystic in an Age of Revolution by Yehudah Mirsky (Yale University Press)
Wyatt Earp: A Vigilante Life by Andrew C. Isenberg (Hill and Wang) Late Life Jazz: The Life and Career of Rosemary Clooney by Ken Crossland & Malcolm Macfarlane (Oxford University Press)

 

All In: Biographers React to the Petraeus-Broadwell Affair

Sales of All In soared after news of the scandal broke.

Sales of All In soared after news of the scandal broke.

Readers rarely come across articles on the craft or ethics of biography in the mainstream media. There are some exceptions, of course: the publication earlier this year of the fourth volume of Robert Caro’s Lyndon Johnson biography drew major coverage in such periodicals as Esquire and Newsweek, and Caro was interviewed on CBS’s Sunday Morning.
Last month, we saw another exception to this rule. When subject and writer have an affair and that affair leads to a public scandal for the subject—a revered popular figure—the ethics of biography soar to the media forefront.
Most TBC readers are by now well aware of the details of the Paula Broadwell–David Petraeus relationship. Their affair, which took place while Broadwell was writing a biography of the CIA head and highly regarded general, sparked a speedy comedown for one of the most influential and powerful public figures of the past decade. More important to BIO members, it publicly raised the professional and ethical dilemmas biographers can face. Those dilemmas go beyond the sexual; Broadwell may have broken the law with the way she handled classified information, though she is unlikely to face any charges.
With the revelation of the affair, some reviewers’ comments about Broadwell’s gushing treatment of her subject seem a little more pointed now. Even the title of the book, All In, raised eyebrows in this new light. And given the sensational nature of the relationship, author has now become subject, as news organizations try to understand Broadwell, what led her to the respected general, how she won his trust, and why she crossed a moral line that ruined his career. (Time will tell how the scandal affects hers.)
Adding some insight was Vernon Loeb, Broadwell’s coauthor and something of a forgotten figure in all this. It was Loeb who took Broadwell’s raw notes from the field and turned them into a book, though he wrote that Broadwell “liberally” revised his text. He also noted in the Washington Post that Broadwell and Petraeus had “an unusually close relationship”—but not one he equated with an extramarital affair.
Below are more of the media’s and BIO members’ reactions to this incident and its implications for biographers in general. Feel free to share your thoughts with us.

“In the end, biographers are much like spies. They seduce their subjects into telling their secrets, which they then use for their own purposes. When they are done, they cast their subject aside, ready to move onto the next. In that sense, the relationship between the Director of the CIA and his biographer was beautifully symmetrical.”
—Emma G. Keller, biographer of Winnie Mandela, in the Guardian

“Any biography of a living, breathing and active figure who’s still at the height of his powers is going to have to strike a delicate balance between access and objectivity. It can be very tricky.”
—Tim Duggan, executive editor at HarperCollins, in the New York Times

“There are not a lot of journalists who would want to get involved in an authorized biography. If you get too close to your subject, you are nothing more than a transcriber, and readers should know that.”
—Carol Felsenthal, biographer of Katharine Graham, among others, in the New York Times

“As with psychiatrists, same with biographers, you shouldn’t sleep with your subject.”
—Blake Bailey, biographer of John Cheever, among others, in the Huffington Post

“She participated in something with her subject that reflects on his character and brings his judgment into question and she didn’t disclose it. It doesn’t even matter much what it was that she did. The real issue is the lack of disclosure of important information like that to the reader.”
—James McGrath Morris, BIO president, in Salon

“You can’t expect to be friends or bosom buddies with the person you write about. If you are, you haven’t done your job. You work for only one person, your reader. You can’t have two masters.”
—David Nasaw, BIO member, in Salon

“For me all of the attention that David Petraeus’s affair with Paula Broadwell has brought to biography seems akin to the proverbial tempest-in-a-teapot. It does not make me rethink the biographer’s relationship to her or his subject. For one thing, how much of a real biographer is Broadwell, who had to pull in a journalist to help her? This does not sound like the working biographers I know. . . . I do not think that the Petraeus-Broadwell situation tells me much about biography. However, it says a great deal about Paula Broadwell and David Petraeus.”
—Gayle Feldman, BIO member, via email

“Broadwell decided to write All In after Harvard asked her to leave the PhD program. This, and other facts coming to light, suggests that rather than looking to become a respected biographer, her main goal was to market herself and salvage her career more broadly. The takeaway from this scandal for me as a biographer? Do not let any effort at promoting my book and myself outstrip the energy I devote to producing a quality work of biography in the first place.”
—Andrew Marble, BIO member, via email

“After the Petraeus/Broadwell mess I’m even more convinced that the authorized biography with all its pureed truths is a cheat to history.”
—Kitty Kelley, BIO member, via email

“Of course, I am following the Petraeus scandal with a keen appetite—after all, it’s a once-in-a-lifetime chance to see the words ‘biographer’ and ‘sexy’ in the same sentence—but the only thought that keeps running through my mind is a self-congratulatory I-told-you: ‘See, this is why I only write about dead people!’ Given that the subject of my first book was a chronic philanderer and my second is a brothel-keeper, my husband has been enthusiastically seconding that thought.”
—Debby Applegate, BIO member, via email