The Biographer’s Craft February 2025

February 2025 | Volume 19 | Number 12

FROM THE EDITOR

I’m sure most of you would agree: we are living in a historic moment. We all know what is in the news and what’s happening in the world, and I will not belabor that point. Instead, I will point you toward the inspiring keynote address that BIO member John “Jack” Farrell gave at last month’s BIO Lab, titled “Is Biography Still Relevant in the Age of X, Trump, and Truthiness?” Spoiler: Jack insists biography is more important now than ever and reminds readers and writers that biography is “uniquely poised” to serve this particular time. You can watch his keynote address here.

The longlist for this year’s Plutarch Award has been decided; the nominees are described below. Nominated by BIO members and publishers, these biographies are being judged by a committee of five distinguished biographers who are also members of BIO. In this issue, we also feature an essay by ALelia Bundles, who will be the keynote speaker this March at our conference “Telling the Stories of Black Lives through Biography” in Montgomery, Alabama. In addition, BIO member James M. Bradley answers Six Questions for us about his recent work. Don’t forget, if you have any ideas for articles about the craft of biography or something you think might inspire your fellow writers, feel free to drop me a line at bionewslettereditors@gmail.com, or fill out the form linked at the end of this newsletter. We all appreciate your voices!

Take care of yourselves and others, and may your words continue to flow this month.

Melanie R. Meadors

PLUTARCH AWARD LONGLIST

The Plutarch Award longlist has just been decided—and BIO members are the first to see the committee’s choices. The award committee this year consists of Ruth Franklin (chair), Vanda Krefft, Lance Richardson, David Maraniss, and Lisa Napoli. Here are their comments on this year’s list:

The 2025 Plutarch Committee reviewed close to 150 books by first-time and experienced biographers, issued by major presses and small academic publishers, on subjects who made their lives in worlds as different as ancient Rome and modern-day Hollywood. Many took the traditional cradle-to-grave approach; a few left us debating whether they should even be called biographies. According to the standards set by earlier committees, we looked for a balance of rigorous research, irresistible writing, and original ideas. Some of these books have already appeared on many other “top ten” and “best of” lists; we’re excited to bring attention to others that will likely be new to you. All of them opened up new worlds to us or offered new perspectives on the familiar.

The titles, listed in alphabetical order by authors’ last names, are as follows (descriptions are drawn from publishers’ websites; names in bold are BIO members):

Max Boot, Reagan: His Life and Legend (Liveright)

Political columnist Max Boot interviewed over 100 of Reagan’s aides, friends, and family members, and researched thousands of newly available documents to write what critics call “the best biography of Ronald Reagan to date.” Boot contextualizes Reagan’s life and provides a nuanced look at the 40th president.

Cynthia Carr, Candy Darling: Dreamer, Icon, Superstar (Farrar, Straus and Giroux)

Cynthia Carr puts Candy Darling, a transgender icon and Warhol film star, back into the spotlight in this meticulously researched biography. Candy Darling died at the young age of 29, in 1974, a time in which conversations about gender identity were just beginning.

Margalit Fox, The Talented Mrs. Mandelbaum: The Rise and Fall of an American Organized-Crime Boss (Random House)

Fredericka Mandelbaum’s rise from tenement poverty to vast wealth in Gilded Age New York City was not a simple rags-to-riches tale. Margalit Fox’s well-researched and flamboyantly told biography captures the fascinating story of a woman who rose through the ranks of New York City society by becoming a criminal mastermind.

Stephanie Gorton, The Icon & the Idealist: Margaret Sanger, Mary Ware Dennett, and the Rivalry That Brought Birth Control to America (HarperCollins)

Stephanie Gorton provides a richly researched and bold perspective on the clash between two women—Margaret Sanger and Mary Ware Dennett—whose activism led the way to the modern discourse over women’s reproductive freedoms. Gorton weaves details of how race, class, and gender, as well as the Great Depression and the eugenics agenda impacted the fight for bodily autonomy and access to birth control into this portrait of rivals whose work affected generations to come.

David Greenberg, John Lewis: A Life (Simon & Schuster)

Most people know of John Lewis’s work in the civil rights movement, but David Greenberg’s biography goes beyond this, covering Lewis’s rise into politics, his work as a voting rights activist, and his dedication to nonviolence and justice. Greenberg uses sources ranging from archives to interviews with almost 300 people, as well as footage of Lewis speaking from his hospital bed in Selma to create a fully dimensional picture of this icon of civil rights and freedom.

Alexis Pauline Gumbs, Survival Is A Promise: The Eternal Life of Audre Lorde (Macmillan)

Alexis Pauline Gumbs is the first researcher to fully explore the depths of Audre Lorde’s manuscript archives. As a result, she has written a biography that captures Lorde’s teachings, creativity, resilience, and her deep engagement with the planet itself in a way that does justice to this force of poetic nature.

Lucy Hughes-Hallet, The Scapegoat: The Brilliant Brief Life of the Duke of Buckingham (Harper)

In a biography that reads much like a novel, Lucy Hughes-Hallet explores the world of the Duke of Buckingham, James I’s confidant, advisor, and lover, and the dynamic world of early modern England.

Heath Hardage Lee, The Mysterious Mrs. Nixon: The Life and Times of Washington’s Most Private First Lady (Macmillan)

Heath Hardage Lee shows the elusive Pat Nixon as few have seen her. While the press portrayed this First Lady as elusive and “plastic,” Nixon did important work for humanitarianism, equal rights, and political policy. This biography portrays a woman that deserved her accolade as the “Most Admired Woman in the World.”

Adam Shatz, The Rebel’s Clinic: The Revolutionary Lives of Frantz Fanon (Macmillan)

This is the thrilling story of Frantz Fanon, the intellectual activist who wrote revolutionary works about race and the psychology of power. His work challenged white supremacy and racial capitalism and still resonates today.

Jackie Wullschläger, Monet: The Restless Vision (Penguin Random House)

Drawing on thousands of letters and unpublished resources, Jackie Wullschläger reveals a new perspective on the life of one of the most important painters of the 19th century, Claude Monet. The author shows how his tumultuous love life impacted his painting and gives readers a new understanding of Monet’s work as well as his life.

MEMBERS’ VOICES

Musings on Black Biography for Young People

Photo by Jimell Greene.

By A’Lelia Bundles

The publication of Joy Goddess: A’Lelia Walker and the Harlem Renaissance on June 10 [by Scribner] will mark the fifth biography I’ve written, but my fascination with the genre began in elementary school during the late 1950s, when I read several books in Bobbs-Merrill’s “Childhood of Famous Americans” series. 

I was drawn to stories about women like author Louisa May Alcott, aviator Amelia Earhart, doctor Elizabeth Blackwell, and Helen Keller. I must have run out of books about women, so I even read about Knute Rockne, Notre Dame’s legendary coach.

But who I didn’t read about was Black people. If the books about Harriet Tubman and Mary McLeod Bethune—the only Black women in the 220-book series—were in my library, it’s hard to believe I would have missed them. I think now what an inspiration it would have been for me as the only little Black girl in my first, second, and third grade classes to actually have seen somebody who looked like me in a book.

Nevertheless, those library books must have planted seeds for On Her Own Ground: The Life and Times of Madam C. J. Walker (Scribner/Lisa Drew, 2001) and my two young adult biographies: All about Madam C. J. Walker (Cardinal/Blue River Press, 2017) and Madam C. J. Walker: Entrepreneur (Chelsea House, 1991).

The Bobbs-Merrill “Childhoods of Famous Americans” series, which began in 1940, was intended to inspire young readers to learn history. And the books did do that, though I now know they were very close to what now would be categorized as the kind of “patriotic education” that sanitizes slavery, glosses over racial discrimination, and gives very little space to women, Native Americans, Latinos, and Asian Americans.

I enjoyed those books as a child, but I’m very happy that young readers today have many more choices with much more diversity and, yes, equity and inclusion. Today, most major publishers have children’s and young adult’s biography series with hundreds of titles. And even if children live in communities where school boards and state legislatures have banned accurate Black history or where libraries won’t stock books about justice-seeking Black people, they can learn about amazing African Americans on Instagram, TikTok, PBS, and hundreds of websites.

A’Lelia Bundles is a BIO member and the author of several biographies, including the upcoming Joy Goddess: A’Lelia Walker and the Harlem Renaissance (Scribner, June 2025).

MEMBER INTERVIEW

Six Questions with James M. Bradley

What is your current project and at what stage is it?

I’ve just begun a biography of Thomas Cooper, a brilliant English-born polymath who emigrated to America in 1794 and became president of South Carolina College. In England, he was a radical, a fierce critic of the slave trade, and a sympathizer of the French Revolution. In America, after a period as a Jeffersonian liberal, he supported slavery, nullification, and secession. He wrote about a wide range of topics, from the sciences and religion to economics and political parties. He also did jailtime for sedition, in 1800. Cooper was famous in his day (Thomas Jefferson called him “the greatest man in America”), but he’s now almost completely forgotten. It will be a short biography, nothing on the scale of my Van Buren book. I like the challenge of bringing an obscure figure back to life. I’m also eager to explore how people can shift so dramatically to embrace the darkest of ideas. 

What person would you most like to write about?

Probably the film director John Ford. It’s a fantasy of mine to write about an artist. I read lots of biographies of novelists, musicians, and filmmakers. I envy those with the skill and knowledge to pull it off. I don’t have the talent for it, though. Biographers, like all writers, must be self-aware. 

Who is your favorite biographer or what is your favorite biography?

That’s a no-brainer: Robert Caro—for his example as much as his output, as thrilling as his books are. I’m in awe of his doggedness and dedication. I’m sure he didn’t intend to spend half a century writing about Lyndon Johnson. I’m sure he didn’t want to. But he decided that that was what was needed, so here we are, in 2025, awaiting the final volume. (Please finish, Mr. Caro!) He truly is peerless. As for my favorite biography, that, too, is a no-brainer: The Power Broker, a 1,200-page page-turner. Honorable mentions: Bernard Bailyn’s The Ordeal of Thomas Hutchinson, Stacy Schiff’s Vera, T. J. Stiles’s The First Tycoon, and Leon Edel’s magisterial multivolume biography of Henry James. 

What have been your most satisfying moments as a biographer?

Finishing the book was pretty satisfying! Other than that, I would say the writing process. Of course, there are moments of discovery in the library and the archives that are exhilarating, but when your writing is clicking—really clicking—there’s no better feeling. Unfortunately, those moments are fleeting and infrequent. I love this quote from Thackeray: “There are a thousand thoughts lying within a man that he does not know till he takes up the pen to write.” How true! I remember when I was finishing the book, I had an inkling of what I wanted the last line to be, but nothing I put down was satisfying. Then, the perfect sentence just came out. I was making a point central to the book, but I somehow had not thought of it in quite that way. The sentence was tucked away in my cerebellum, and then magically it appeared on screen. It’s one of the few lines in the book that I didn’t amend at all. My editor didn’t touch it, either. (Sorry, I’m not quoting it here; you’ll have to get the book and judge for yourself.)

What have been your most frustrating moments?

The opposite of everything I just wrote. Writing is a draining, brutal slog. Things almost never go smoothly. And just when you think you find your rhythm, you hit a wall. Rinse, wash, repeat. Also dispiriting is the fruitless quest for material—driving for hours to the archives only to find nothing of any value. Then there’s the painful realization that there are limits to what we know. This comes with the profession when you write about people who lived a long time ago. We search for material to patch together a narrative, but there are often glaring gaps in the record. I know so little about Van Buren’s childhood, for example, and what kind of relationship he had with his parents, even his wife. Sometimes I picture Van Buren reading my book, laughing at my attempts to understand and explain the past, where, as a novelist once famously wrote, they do things differently.

What genre, besides biography, do you read for pleasure and who are some of your favorite writers?

Sometimes I need a break from a steady diet of U.S. history, so I’ll jump into contemporary fiction. The best of the recent lot is Joseph O’Neill’s Godwin: A Novel (Pantheon, 2024), an absorbing and powerful book. I also read a lot of history outside my field and general nonfiction. Peter Frankopan’s work, which I’ve only recently discovered, is remarkable. When I need to unwind, I often turn to memoirs and diaries; I just finished Francine Prose’s terrific 1974: A Personal History (Harper, 2024), and I’m now into Lucy Sante’s I Heard Her Call My Name: A Memoir of Transition (Penguin Press, 2024). Favorite writer: Gore Vidal. If I could only have one book (what a terrifying thought!), it would be his United States: Essays 1952–1992, and I would probably never be bored. Other favorites (in no order) are: Henry Adams, Vivian Gornick, Richard Hofstadter, Tocqueville, John Lukacs, V. S. Naipaul, Tony Judt, Philip Roth, David Lodge (RIP) . . . I could go on, but I’ll stop there. Oh, and I just started [Pynchon’s] Gravity’s Rainbow—this is the year I do it! Check in with me in 12 months.

James M. Bradley is the author of Martin Van Buren: America’s First Politician, published by Oxford University Press, in December 2024.

AMANUENSIS

“Why Biography?”

By Megan Marshall
(Originally published in Commonplace: The Journal of Early American Life)

I love biography. I always have. As a girl, I spent countless hours in the town library where my grandmother ran the children’s room. There I discovered a series of biographies of famous women—Amelia Earhart and Marie Curie are the ones I remember best. I thrilled to those life stories, which stressed the sense of adventure or mission these accomplished women felt inwardly, even as young girls. Back home, I took apart my roller skates and attached the wheels to the bottom of a wooden box, in an effort to build a go-cart like one the young Amelia Earhart was said to have launched down a ramp off the roof of a work shed in an early attempt to fly.

When I was in the sixth grade, my school piloted a silent-reading program that allowed our class of 32 eleven-year-olds, housed in a portable classroom on the sunbaked black-top of a Southern California playground in 1964, to choose and read at our own pace selections, many of which were drawn from biographies of African American women. Looking back on that year, I can see us sitting quietly at our desks, the children of parents driven west by the dust bowl disaster, of Japanese Americans interned during World War II, of immigrants from Mexico—all thrust back, imaginatively, into a different America from any we’d known or heard of as we read about Harriet Tubman and Mary McLeod Bethune, whose evocative, musical names provoked me to pause and mouth the syllables into the unaccustomed stillness. FULL ARTICLE

Amanuensis: A person whose employment is to write what another dictates, or to copy what another has written. Source: Webster’s Revised Unabridged Dictionary (1913).

BIO PODCAST

Samantha Ege, Cheryl Janifer LaRoche,
and Mary Frances Phillips

Recently on episode number 203 of the BIO Podcast, BIO member Sonja Williams interviewed internationally recognized concert pianist and London-based popular public speaker Samantha Ege about her first book, South Side Impresarios: How Race Women Transformed Chicago’s Classical Music Scene (University of Illinois Press, 2024). Episode number 204 features BIO member Kevin McGruder’s interview with fellow member Cheryl Janifer LaRoche, an archaeologist and scholar whose book Apostle of Liberation: AME Bishop Paul Quinn and the Underground Railroad was published this month by Rowman and Littlefield. And episode 205 features Sonja Williams chatting with Mary Frances Phillips, historian and author of Black Panther Woman: The Political and Spiritual Life of Ericka Huggins, published in January by New York University Press.

PITCH YOUR ARTICLE

Would you like to see your work featured in The Biographer’s Craft? Simply fill out this form to submit your pitch. Remember, features should be focused on the art and craft of biography, should not be promotional, and must be written by BIO members. Submit your pitch here.

KEEP YOUR INFO CURRENT

Making a move or just changed your email? We ask BIO members to keep their contact information up to date, so we and other members know where to find you. Update your information in the Member Area of the BIO website.

MEMBERSHIP UP FOR RENEWAL?

Please respond promptly to your membership renewal notice. As a nonprofit organization, BIO depends on members’ dues to fund our annual conference, the publication of this newsletter, and the other work we do to support biographers around the world.

BIO BOARD OF DIRECTORS

Steve Paul, President
Heather Clark, Vice President
Marc Leepson, Treasurer
Kathleen Stone, Secretary
Michael Gately, Executive Director
Kai Bird
Natalie Dykstra
Gretchen Holbrook Gerzina
Carla Kaplan
Kitty Kelley
Diane Kiesel
Sarah S. Kilborne
Linda Leavell
Heath Lee
Susan Page
Tamara Payne
Barbara Lehman Smith
Will Swift
Eric K. Washington
Sonja D. Williams


ADVISORY COUNCIL

Debby Applegate, Chair • Taylor Branch • A’Lelia Bundles • Robert Caro • Ron Chernow • Tim Duggan • John A. Farrell • Caroline Fraser • Irwin Gellman • Michael Holroyd • Peniel Joseph • Hermione Lee • David Levering Lewis • Andrew Lownie • Megan Marshall • John Matteson • Jon Meacham • Marion Meade • Candice Millard • James McGrath Morris • Andrew Morton • Hans Renders • Stacy Schiff • Gayfryd Steinberg • T. J. Stiles • Rachel Swarns • William Taubman • Claire Tomalin

THE BIOGRAPHER'S CRAFT

Editor
Jared Stearns

Associate Editor
Melanie R. Meadors

Consulting Editor
James McGrath Morris

Copy Editor
Margaret Moore Booker